Welcome to Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream
At Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream, nestled in East Falmouth, MA, the passion for quality is palpable. This charming spot is celebrated for its rich, housemade flavors, ranging from classic to unique, like Ginger and Red Raspberry Truffle. Locally sourced ingredients ensure a creamy experience that delights every palate. The welcoming atmosphere, filled with benches and blooming flowers, invites families to enjoy their sweet treats outdoors. Young, community-driven staff add a personal touch to every visit. With over 20 flavors and homemade delights, Smitty's offers not just ice cream, but a cherished experience worth the trip.
- 326 E Falmouth Hwy, East Falmouth, MA 02536 Hotline: (508) 457-1060
Welcome to Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream, the charming ice cream sanctuary nestled at 326 E Falmouth Hwy, East Falmouth, MA 02536. If you're searching for a delightful scoop that encapsulates the essence of homemade goodness, look no further. This beloved local gem, often hailed as a hometown favorite, prides itself on crafting not just ice cream, but an experience that tantalizes the taste buds and warms the heart.
As you step into Smitty's, you’re welcomed by a vibrant atmosphere filled with laughter and cheer, thanks to a lively team comprised of enthusiastic young folks from the community. It's evident in their attentive service that they are passionate about creating enjoyable moments for every guest. Many patrons rave about the friendly vibes, noting the inviting outdoor seating adorned with beautiful flowers, making it an ideal spot to relish your treats.
- Quality Flavors: With over 20 unique flavors, Smitty's offers an impressive selection that caters to every craving. From classic combinations like Chocolate Peanut Butter to intriguing options such as Ginger and Red Raspberry Truffle, every scoop promises quality and creativity.
- Homemade Happiness: Every aspect of the ice cream, including toppings and whipped cream, is made from scratch, ensuring that each indulgence is packed with rich, decadent flavor. The standout, as noted by customers, is the housemade strawberry topping, which features chunks of real strawberries – a treat not to be missed!
- Sustainable Community Support: Customers appreciate that when you toss a few dollars into the tip jar, it goes directly towards the college funds of the young staff, adding a warm, community-focused dimension to your visit.
Pricing is slightly on the higher side, but the superb quality justifies the cost; after all, you are savoring lovingly crafted, homemade ice cream. As one satisfied customer aptly noted, “You can definitely tell that the ice cream is homemade,” and it’s this authenticity that keeps guests returning for more, even if they have to drive some distance. You won’t just get a scoop; you’ll get a slice of a heartwarming local tradition.
With rave reviews across the board, Smitty's Homemade Ice Cream is a testament to the magic of creamy delights served up in a setting that embodies the spirit of East Falmouth. So whether you’re stopping by for a quick treat or lounging on a bench with family and friends, the experience at Smitty’s is bound to leave an indelible sweetness in your memory!
For inquiries or to plan your visit, you can reach Smitty's at (508) 457-1060. Treat yourself to a beautiful scoop of happiness today!

The ice cream is amazing! Delicious and rich. It's a small place, but plenty of benches to sit on, and flowers to relax by. The staff are young folks from the community. If you can, feel free to throw a few dollars into the tip jar as it goes to their college fund(s)

If you want a great ice cream in small quantities- Smitty's is your place. The quality is superb but the quantity for the price is expensive! A hometown favorite who is worth a try!!

Awesome! Great Service. Plenty of selection. Tons of room to eat outside. Great parking.

Sooo excited we drove 25 minutes for this ice cream! Everything was top notch and housemade from the ice cream to the topping to the whipped cream! We came before the summer season and you can tell the new teens we're being trained so we were happy to help! The biggest win was the housemade strawberry topping with chunks of real strawberry (think strawberry shortcake). Next level! Get a sundae so you can try their house made whipped cream!

When an ice cream shop has over 20 flavors, it's either going to be the best ice cream you've ever had or a major letdown. I think it's safe to say that Smitty's is more the former than the latter. They have a wide assortment of flavors that will satisfy even the pickiest customer, including bizarre options like Ginger and Red raz truffle. I decided to try their chocolate peanut butter and coffee oreo. It was deliciously creamy with just the right amount of toppings mixed in. Although a small will cost you more than 5 bucks, you can definitely tell that the ice cream is homemade. 5 stars all around!

Super cute spot to pick up an ice cream with the family. They had a ton of flavors to choose from. The ones I tried were really good, but they weren't at creamy as I would have liked. I would definitely go back and try more flavors though!

To whoever said the line moves quick is an understatement . Never have I ever been served ice cream as quick as I have here. Wanted the red truffle ice cream everyone is taking pictures of but was sold out so settled with small orange pineapple. Spot on flavor and consistency. Good thing I don't have five gallons of this sitting at home, I would be in trouble!